I think it's decent. The shorter 8 hour timer allows several collections a day. Sometimes there are double drops of both Lumin and Enchanters. That being said, I do not know if this is one of those items like the Fire Fly Cove where drops can be "lucky" or "unlucky" overall. For instance, some here say their Fire Fly Cove regularly drops Trade Tickets, but mine do not. But all 4 of my accounts have Petunias, a few have 2, and when I need to bump up my stock I start collecting from them twice a day. I also have a few other droppers, so I can't say for sure the exact rate of this particular one.