Originally Posted by
SpiritWind00
Yes, the goal says you need to make one, not have one. Did you make one before or after the goal? If is was after, please force close your game for it to register. Otherwise, you will need to craft another ice lily.
Also, make sure you do the fire one first and collect before you collect an ice lily for the to complete. There is more info in post 2 of this thread to help you. Having multiple lilies will help in the next chapter though, so they will come in handy.