I got my Obsidian Cyclops after my last post here! It can be done but it was the longest and most boring try for any animal in my Forest so far. I didn't like the looks of the Cyclops in the beginning but now that I have him I find him quite adorable.
My luck is back it seems and I not only got this little guy but I bred my second Money Badger as well. They are out there but it can be extremely frustrating when you try and try with nothing to show for it. Don't give up hope folks. I have seen it happen