Don't hate me but after turning in 4 collections and getting the Rose Arch, the Valentine's Basket, the Heart Candles, and the Heart Shaped Topiary, I'd given up. I still had two more collections I could have turned in, but didn't as I figured I'd give it a rest and hope for something better today.
Well, it turned out I played my collection right, as I just turned in another collection, first of the day today, and I got the Valentine's Puppy. I haven't purchased any animals for my farm as I couldn't afford the Gems or the Cash, needed it for the buildings, so this is a first for me. A first in having an animal and a first that I actually got one of the better prized from a "chance" collection.
Don't hate me.