Quote Originally Posted by mudkipsssssss View Post
I crafted a Garnett Trinket and when I collected it it just gave me a life trinket I dont want to waste more lanterns going on another adventure to get another piece of Garnett
It may take a few tries to get the Garnett Trinket.

Quote Originally Posted by glimmergate View Post
The Faeries are determined to prevent you from making the Garnet Trinket! They're using their magic to try and make you fail. It might take a few tries before you can successfully craft the trinket!