My ponds give me more than one water. I get 3 from the troll pond and I think the coi. I have all my shards. Do you have your shards? They really help out. If you don?t look it up. There are 4 of them. I hope they add another one with the higher levels however they did add drops when you are at 7 and 8. Once you get all your regular items on the board only one of each to level 5 make sure that you collect from the tablet of tabernum and it is pointed in the same way you found it or if it won?t drop the shards. I especially liked the energy you get back from collecting from your garden like in the very beginning of the game. Just in case you are only getting one water. I always get at least two or more.