Will not accept the baskets I've made for Josie the otter challenge when I tap give??

I've already completed the 7/7 Otterly Sweet Challenges as well as the Jeremiah the otter challenge. It says I have 7 days left and I'm trying to complete Josie the otter challenge in my to do list. I've completed the five baskets, but when I am tapping give it will not fulfil the item. They are in my warehouse, so I'm not sure what else I'm supposed to do? Please help!

Welcome to the forum and congrats on getting Jeremiah. :)

Can you check if you have the correct item in your barn? The Josie goal requires 5 Otterly Perfect Presents to fulfil the task. The Otterly Perfect Presents are made in the Studio.