It's eminently doable - the only problem were the truffles (if I'm not mistaken, you need 99 for each pet). Also, make sure you're stocked up on mermaid scales and living wood. The rest was easy to obtain.
They need dragon scales, truffles, manticor wiskers. That is for the cat. I still need truffles to finish the dog. I do not think i will get the cat.
"Doable" with 50 Faerie Jar when we have spent all of them and more on the "Scorched Search"?
Started giving up some inventory, then noticed the 3 day timer. It may be eminently doable for some, but definitely not for me. No way I can get another 70 truffles in that time frame. I don't have a manticore and just got a dragon, so scales and whiskers not doable either. Please don't give us these goals with a timer!
bambisden: I did the exact same thing Until I saw the deadline Well, what's done is done...
I was trying for the puppy--manticore whiskers put the kitty out of reach--but haven't gotten nearly enough living wood. Oh well!